Is matcha the new pumpkin spice? Gen Z’s obsession vs. millennial’s fall favorite

The fall flavor debate is heating up

For years, pumpkin spice has owned the fall flavor crown. It’s the latte you reach for when leaves turn and cardigans come out. But now, there’s a new player sipping its way into autumn, matcha.

Loved by Gen Z, this antioxidant-rich green tea has sparked a subtle takeover. Is it really dethroning pumpkin spice or just carving out its own corner?

Let’s compare their popularity, cultural power, and future potential in the great seasonal beverage battle.

Pumpkin spice isn’t going anywhere

Pumpkin spice is practically fall’s scent track. It triggers nostalgia, warmth, and comfort, especially for Millennials, who turned it into a full-blown seasonal trend.

Starbucks first dropped the pumpkin spice latte (PSL) in 2003. Since then, it’s become a cultural marker. From lattes to candles, even dog treats, pumpkin spice is now a $1.2 billion industry, expected to more than double by 2035. That’s a long way from just another syrup pump.

The health halo behind matcha

Matcha didn’t rise to fame by accident. Gen Z, the wellness-obsessed, TikTok-scrolling generation, wants more from their drinks than a sugar rush. Matcha offers that.

It’s energizing without the crash, loaded with antioxidants, and comes with calming L-theanine. That’s a rare combo in the caffeine world. That alone makes it more than a seasonal pick-me-up.

Fall exclusivity vs. year-round appeal

Here’s where pumpkin spice starts to lose ground. It’s trapped in a time capsule, September to November. Outside of fall, it feels… off. Matcha? It’s an all-season player.

Iced matcha lattes in summer, hot in winter, and blended with oat milk whenever you want. Its flexibility gives it more staying power on menus and in morning routines. In short: pumpkin spice is a moment, matcha is a habit.

A look at the numbers

The pumpkin spice market is booming, $2.8 billion by 2035. But matcha is sprinting too. In Canada alone, matcha sales hit $300 million in 2024 and are set to reach $700 million soon after.

Matcha’s growth is faster and more global. And here’s the kicker: cafés report actual matcha shortages due to demand. That’s not seasonal hype. That’s a shift in consumer behavior.

The TikTok effect

Pumpkin spice walked so matcha could go viral. Social media has made matcha cool, the ritual of whisking it, the vibrant green color, and the aesthetic iced drinks. It’s everywhere on TikTok, with creators touting it as the “clean energy” alternative to coffee.

Gen Z doesn’t just drink it; they post it, brand it, and build entire routines around it. Pumpkin spice might trend for a few months, but matcha’s presence feels constant and curated.

Nostalgia vs. wellness

Pumpkin spice thrives on nostalgia. It reminds people of cozy fall days, childhood baking sessions, and warm memories. That’s powerful, but not future-proof.

Matcha fits into wellness-driven routines: gym, journaling, green smoothie, matcha latte. It’s ritual, not indulgence. And in a wellness economy, rituals win. The new generation of drinkers wants function over comfort. Or maybe, they want both, but with less sugar.

But Millennials love matcha now too

It’s not just a Gen Z thing anymore. Millennials, many of whom started the PSL craze, are jumping into the matcha game too.

Especially as health priorities shift in their 30s and 40s. They’re looking to reduce coffee crashes, cut back on sugar, and find beverages that align with wellness trends.

Matcha checks those boxes. It’s less of a generational divide now and more of a shared shift.

Matcha isn’t just in drinks

One reason matcha’s thriving? It’s not just about lattes. Matcha is now in protein powders, collagen blends, desserts, skincare, and even cocktails. It’s versatile, and brands are leaning into that.

Pumpkin spice has tried this too (we’ve seen the candles, granola bars, and oddly, deodorants), but it often feels forced. Matcha’s crossover into wellness and beauty feels more organic, pun intended.

When pumpkin spice meets matcha

Here’s where things get interesting, hybrid drinks. Pumpkin spice matcha lattes are trending in cafes across cities. It’s the flavor of fall with the energy of matcha.

That combo says a lot: the two aren’t enemies. In fact, they might be better together. It’s an example of how tradition and modern wellness can blend (literally) to reflect what today’s consumers want, which is flavor, function, and fun.

Is the matcha hype real?

It’s easy to brush off matcha as a Gen Z fad, but the numbers and the demand say otherwise. This isn’t a flash-in-the-pan trend. The café orders, product launches, and market growth all point to something more permanent.

It’s become a daily staple for many, not just a seasonal pick. The hype might’ve started online, but it’s clearly sticking offline too.

What brands are betting on

Big brands are paying attention. Starbucks has expanded its matcha offerings. So have chains like Dunkin’ and Tim Hortons. Grocery aisles are now stocked with matcha mixes, canned lattes, and even matcha-flavored wellness bars.

When mainstream brands go beyond just testing, and start stocking, that’s usually a sign the trend has moved to mainstay.

Matcha fits modern priorities

Let’s be honest: people today care more about what they’re putting into their bodies. Clean energy, gut health, sugar reduction, all of that matters.

Pumpkin spice is tasty but doesn’t exactly scream “clean.” Matcha, on the other hand, leans hard into that lifestyle. In the age of label-reading and ingredient-tracking, matcha just makes more sense.

But pumpkin spice still owns the season

Don’t count pumpkin spice out just yet. It still dominates fall. Its cultural relevance, emotional attachment, and seasonal buzz keep it at the top of mind come September. It’s less about function and more about feeling.

And feelings sell, especially when wrapped in whipped cream and cinnamon. That emotional value is something matcha may never fully replicate.

Matcha might even take over iced coffee next

It’s not just pumpkin spice that matcha is going after; cold coffee is next on the list. Iced coffee, cold brews, and frappes have been go-to drinks for both Millennials and Gen Z for years.

But now, iced matcha lattes are popping up everywhere. They’re lighter, less jittery, and still give a nice energy boost. Plus, they look great on social media. A lot of people are starting to swap their iced coffee for a green matcha, especially in the summer.

Ready to trade in your iced coffee for a green glow-up? See how Gen Z is flipping more than just their drinks.

So, which cup are you holding this fall?

Maybe you’re loyal to your iced coffee or PSL. Maybe you’ve already made matcha your morning staple. Or maybe like many, you’ve got both on rotation, depending on the vibe.

PSL brings comfort, iced coffee keeps us going, and matcha offers calm energy with a wellness edge. Each sip reflects what we value, from tradition to health to aesthetic.

Craving more sippable insights? Let’s break down the tasty difference between Thai tea and milk tea.

What’s in your cup this season? PSL, cold brew, or a bright green matcha? Share in the comments.

Read More From This Brand:

• Different Types of Alcoholic Drinks (Comparison)
• Dr. Pepper Or Mr-Pibb? (Explained)
• The Ultimate Guide to Choosing Between Frestec and Igloo Refrigerators

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.